Welcome to the new Goldfrapp forum. Enjoy your new home! X
Silver Eye (main album thread)
  • 1576 Comments sorted by
  • Vote Up0Vote Down cookiee_munstercookiee_munster
    Posts: 651
    it's so weird seeing her as a red head - she does look great though :D
  • Vote Up0Vote Down LowLow
    Posts: 906
    Calling a Goldfrapp track is utterly horrible is like accusing somebody of murder. You have to be really, really sure that's it's true and tbh it's probably not.

  • Vote Up0Vote Down Halloween_JackHalloween_Jack
    Posts: 2,293
    Low said:

    Calling a Goldfrapp track is utterly horrible is like accusing somebody of murder. You have to be really, really sure that's it's true and tbh it's probably not.



    Someone said a track was horrible? Which, where?
    Avondale guesthouse
  • Vote Up0Vote Down LowLow
    Posts: 906
    Slippage said:

    One minute snippets of each track leaked on youtube.




    SPOILER WARNING

    Become The One is the strangest track I've heard by them. Not liking the vocal treatment at all. Need to hear more though - perhaps it's salvageable. As it stands, though, I think it's utterly horrible and could have been something really special.



    Lots of praise after that but it just struck me as strange lol.

  • Vote Up0Vote Down lukasgardinerlukasgardiner
    Posts: 154
    Low said:

    Calling a Goldfrapp track is utterly horrible is like accusing somebody of murder. You have to be really, really sure that's it's true and tbh it's probably not.



    well i didn't like 'anymore' when i heard the clip yet somehow the song has been on repeat on my iPod ever since the full track came out... odd how that happens isn't it? 
  • Vote Up0Vote Down LowLow
    Posts: 906
    lukasgardiner said:

    Low said:

    Calling a Goldfrapp track is utterly horrible is like accusing somebody of murder. You have to be really, really sure that's it's true and tbh it's probably not.



    well i didn't like 'anymore' when i heard the clip yet somehow the song has been on repeat on my iPod ever since the full track came out... odd how that happens isn't it? 


    Yeah that's cool when that happens. Feel like you're trying to make a point.

  • Vote Up0Vote Down Urban_TribesmanUrban_Tribesman
    Posts: 5,681
    Halloween_Jack said:

    Odd that Mute never responded to you!?

    Fascination management didn't get back to me either BTW. Do they still cover Goldfrapp? Well, their webpage seems to say so (albeit an old pic)... http://www.fascinationmanagement.com/


    I got fed up in the end HJ. As you know, I tried to tell them there was a leak but you can lead a horse to water etc etc.
    I had just DM'd A is A on Twit as I think she has a follow from Alison so could PM her on there to tell her, but by the time I did that, the ZDigital link had been pulled, it was on YouTube, then that was pulled...
    Anyway, cats out the bag now and I no longer feel I am holding out on people.
    The Moving Finger writes; and, having writ.
    Moves on: nor all thy Piety nor Wit.
    Shall lure it back to cancal half a line,
    Nor all thy Tears wash out a Word of it.
  • Vote Up0Vote Down GaelenGaelen
    Posts: 321
    My only issue with Become The One is it sounds so similar to Pale Green Ghosts that it's all it makes me think of when I listened to the clip, almost as if the producer is a bit of a one trick pony when it comes to musical talent.  As much as that makes the guy unique and identifiable, it just smacks of a lack of originality considering I first listened to that John Grant album in the summer of '13.  

    Having said that, I do like the song and I do like the sound of it (particularly the breezing vocals), it's one of the clips where the 60 seconds didn't do it any justice.

    The clips did at least fill me with confidence that I will enjoy the album immensely upon release and for eternity.  But it also squashed some pre-conceived ideas that I had in my head of what certain songs would have sounded like from their zingy titles, e.g. Zodiac Black i'd have thought was going to be a stomper - which it is not - and had I stayed with that thought for another two months I might have been a bit underwhelmed.
    Post edited by Gaelen at 2017-02-08 17:36:25
    Soon be nothing of this world.
  • Vote Up0Vote Down SlippageSlippage
    Posts: 409
    Low said:

    lukasgardiner said:

    Low said:

    Calling a Goldfrapp track is utterly horrible is like accusing somebody of murder. You have to be really, really sure that's it's true and tbh it's probably not.



    well i didn't like 'anymore' when i heard the clip yet somehow the song has been on repeat on my iPod ever since the full track came out... odd how that happens isn't it? 


    Yeah that's cool when that happens. Feel like you're trying to make a point.


    Fair enough. To me, in my opinion, the track sounds horrible in comparison to what the rest of the album sounds like. That being said, it is only a minute-long snippet and it could just be a poorly selected section of the track. Could have a killer chorus or sudden abrupt changes.

    Still, can't be expected to like every song they produce. Can't tell you the backlash I've received from countless Madonna fans for not being able to stand specific songs, or from Cher fans for liking certain ones.
    Just can't win! 

    Lol. That being said, the album is sounding fantastic altogether. Very glad I pre-ordered, as always.

    I'm really shocked that Zodiac Black isn't something akin to Strict Machine, as others and myself had expected/hoped. The middle of the album feels pretty damn saggy without an uptempo bump between the chunk of slower songs if we're going by the snippets.
    Post edited by Slippage at 2017-02-08 17:43:36
  • Vote Up0Vote Down GaelenGaelen
    Posts: 321
    Off-topic, but out of interest, what Madonna songs are in question here? :P
    Soon be nothing of this world.
  • Vote Up0Vote Down ryanraymedinaryanraymedina
    Posts: 76
    @Gaelen, I'm a bit confused by your critique of Become The One... I thought the only John producer on the new album is John Congleton, and not John Grant?
  • Vote Up0Vote Down LowLow
    Posts: 906
    Slippage said:

    Low said:

    lukasgardiner said:

    Low said:

    Calling a Goldfrapp track is utterly horrible is like accusing somebody of murder. You have to be really, really sure that's it's true and tbh it's probably not.



    well i didn't like 'anymore' when i heard the clip yet somehow the song has been on repeat on my iPod ever since the full track came out... odd how that happens isn't it? 


    Yeah that's cool when that happens. Feel like you're trying to make a point.


    Fair enough. To me, in my opinion, the track sounds horrible in comparison to what the rest of the album sounds like. That being said, it is only a minute-long snippet and it could just be a poorly selected section of the track. Could have a killer chorus or sudden abrupt changes.

    Still, can't be expected to like every song they produce. Can't tell you the backlash I've received from countless Madonna fans for not being able to stand specific songs, or from Cher fans for liking certain ones.
    Just can't win! 

    Lol. That being said, the album is sounding fantastic altogether. Very glad I pre-ordered, as always.

    I'm really shocked that Zodiac Black isn't something akin to Strict Machine, as others and myself had expected/hoped. The middle of the album feels pretty damn saggy without an uptempo bump between the chunk of slower songs if we're going by the snippets.


    Hey, I never said you weren't allowed to call it what you want but doing so on a 1 minute snippet always seems a bit pointless to me.  >:D< Maybe the songs just explode near the end, we don't know. And won't hopefully until the end of March.

  • Vote Up0Vote Down SlippageSlippage
    Posts: 409
    Gaelen said:

    Off-topic, but out of interest, what Madonna songs are in question here? :P



    Oh, there's no way I'll let that slip out! Lol. I've been sent enough insult-laden messages in all-caps over it. I will say that Confessions and Ray of Light are brilliant albums, and songs such as Gone, You'll See, Live To Tell and The Power of Goodbye are my absolute favourites.
  • Vote Up0Vote Down SlippageSlippage
    Posts: 409
    Low said:

    Slippage said:

    Low said:

    lukasgardiner said:

    Low said:

    Hey, I never said you weren't allowed to call it what you want but doing so on a 1 minute snippet always seems a bit pointless to me.  >:D< Maybe the songs just explode near the end, we don't know. And won't hopefully until the end of March.



    Oh, but don't think I'm trying to be defensive! If anything I agree with your points, so please don't take my response the wrong way. It's so much harder to sound human and peaceable online than in person...

    I agree completely that we will know more in March, and that's just fine with me. Like I also said (and agree with you about), it's only minute-long snippets for now, and the song in question could change as it goes along. At any rate, I'm looking forward to the video tomorrow - very Mad Max Fury Road!
    Post edited by Slippage at 2017-02-08 18:07:44
  • Vote Up0Vote Down GaelenGaelen
    Posts: 321

    ryanraymedina said:

    @Gaelen, I'm a bit confused by your critique of Become The One... I thought the only John producer on the new album is John Congleton, and not John Grant?



    I might not have projected what I meant clearly.  I never meant John Grant was the producer, but the producer who produced Grant's album Pale Green Ghosts (which is actually the one you mentioned, John Congleton) is who I was referring to as being a one trick pony in reference to that particular album.

    I suppose when we have the wonderful duo to compare against (who seldom repeat) then it makes life more difficult. 

    @Slippage - If you had said MDNA, or perhaps some of Rebel Heart we might have been onto something.
    Post edited by Gaelen at 2017-02-08 18:06:59
    Soon be nothing of this world.
Add a Comment

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Sign In Apply for Membership

Categories